Cmack's Survivor ran from August 2010 until June 2017. It featured hundreds of players over the course of 50 total seasons.
The following list ranks the "SEASONS" taking into account the following information: Casting, Twists, Entertainment, etc.
PART 1/10
#50: Cook Islands(season 9)
-When there were 9 seasons, it was ranked as the worst. Ever since it occurred, some seasons have come close to lowering the standard of a season, but they never did. A ton of inactivity in this cast with the exception of a handful of players that made the merge. This season did produce 2 of the most memorable players( titan24maniac and DEADBEATJONAH14), who won a combined 5 times after appearing.
#49: Indonesia(season 43)
-On paper, this season looked like something any host could dream of. The cast, the twist, the expectations...it was all hype. While the season itself played out, the controversial dark cloud that loomed over the coaches and the even more controversial ending that resulted in the first and only disqualification of a “winner”, makes this season one of the worst in the series.
#48: Congo(season 44)
-3 medical evacuations due to self votes, including one of the most obvious Final 2 alliances in the game...and one of the quickest Final Immunity Challenges of all time. This season lacked a lot and it followed a season that really lowered the bar, and they just barely got over the bar.
#47: Guatemala(season 14)
-At the time, this season was more of a mid-tier game but after looking back through it, the twist of 2 returning winners joining the cast to “help” the players backfired and those 2 winners managed to take all of the newbies out of the game and leave themselves at the end. While the finalists would disagree, this season was one of the least interesting of the series.
#46: Bolivia(season 42)
-The casting process for this season was terrifying. 24 hours before the game was set to begin, the cast was going to only feature 14 people, an all-time low in the history of this series. I decided to put 2 returnees in, 1 former winner and a former finalist. While I didn’t expect anything to happen and figured they would both go early, this season crowned an unexpected 2-time winner, just one of 2 in the 3rd Generation. Also, it had one of my least favorite twists, a tribe swap every single day of the pre-merge.
Cmack's Survivor ran from August 2010 until June 2017. It featured hundreds of players over the course of 50 total seasons.