This poll was posted over on Reddit to see which of these classic players they'd like to return. That's not the crazy part. The insane part is that the poll uses MODERN pictures of them, and they all look completely different. I guarantee Brandon Quinton is unrecognizable. And Jonathan Libby. Gregg Carey from Palau looks like Ken McNickle!
LMAOOOOOOOOOO @ MICHELLE BEING A LAS VEGAS DJ WHAT
Jessie looks gorgeous though, bring her back. and holy fuck @ Jonathan Libby. what happened
it'd be a fucking amazing twist though. see who's actually a super fan and can sus it out
gabriel cade actually auditioned again (i forget for which season) and he made it through a few rounds before casting realized he was on the show before