Yes, this is literally EVERY single player to ever go unnommed except for unnommed players who got glitched out. I know like none of you will read all of this but just skim through it!
Some info before you read the rest:
41/106 unnommed people won the game.
16 times did 2 people go unnommed in the same game.
Most times going unnommed for one player was 4 by #surstromming who only won once and #corey1 with 4 who never won going unnommed.
Most Stars wins ever was #Emmaleigh with 6 [15, 24, 33, 59, 95, 139]
Findings:
When 2 people went to finals unnommed, there votes split and they both lose the game despite their phenomenal game play. This happened almost every time.
When people realized that letting people go unnommed was a dumb idea and the game play of stars evolved, it slowed down a ton.
Stars 25- #Cosgrove and #2cool4school (IRL brothers make it unnommed together, both lose to #BioDork on the 2nd closest vote ever. Bio only won with 35.3%! #Cosgrove's 2nd time going unnommed and losing)
Stars 108- #TheRealMessiah (Claims he didn't deserve the win so everyone voted for #Bella777 instead)
Stars 113- #jakelovespicklerr (On his previous account he was flavored twice and won both times, this time he took a dose of his own medicine and received 3rd to the flavor #Yoki)
Stars 117- #Austin (Receives 3rd to #Phenomanimal in the first 17 person glitched stars)
Stars 120- #joe1110 (Doing as he usually does, he logs off for like half the game. But he went all the way this time and still got 3rd to #ZEEnon)
Stars 121- #ronron313 and @TinaBeena (In the 20 person stars, they received 1st and 2nd with #ronron313 getting 39.6% while #TinaBeena lost by only .7%)
Stars 122- #JesseM (Received 3rd to #Etienne who got 37.1% of the vote)
Stars 128- #ianfitz0012 (Wins with 42.8% of the vote)
Stars 144- #ladylizard (Wins with 35.9% of the vote)
Stars 154- #princesskk (Wins with 40.2% of the vote after many finals, this time unnommed)
Stars 155- #Rockon_88 (Wins with 46.5% of the vote)
Stars 161- #Markb101 (Receives 2nd to #Snoofle who was nommed 4 times)
Stars 162- #aquamarine (2nd time going unnommed was the charm as he won with 45.5%)
Stars 184- #Splozojames50 (2nd place to the flavor #Seal in his first stars)
Stars 188- meduncan (Wins with 43.8% in Partner Stars!)
Stars 192- jm101 (Wins with 39.4% after being robbed countless times after going unnommed, he did it this time)
Stars 215- meduncan (His 2nd time going unnommed didn't get him the win, #SamSam14 won while #meduncan sat in 3rd place)
Stars 225- #jessebruenger (He's never been THAT popular or well known, and getting to finals with #TheSexiestDude990 was the death of him! He took 2nd while Julian walked away with a smile on his face)
Stars 227- Manda17_xoxo and Bradd156 (Once again, when 2 people go unnommed in the same game their votes split. So #bradd156's 2nd time going unnommed still didn't pay off as he took 3rd, #manda17_xoxo took 2nd, and #Dools won)
Stars 236- charming2010 (2nd time was the charm for him! Won with 44.2%)
Stars 237- jakel0vespicklerr (His 2nd time going unnommed on his 2nd account where he became a gameplayer instead of a flavor paid off as he won with 45.2%)
Stars 242- robinhood99 (In his 1st stars, he was triumphed by the old school player #frozen who finally got his stars win. Although #robinhood99 was robbed taking 2nd place, #frozen had the same thing happen to him once, but he won as a flavor!)
Stars 257- SilentSwordsman (The noob who shocked everyone.... won with 41.1% of the vote breaking the unnommed person losing streak)
Stars 258- #alireza1373 (I'm sorry but how THE FUCK did they let this guy go unnommed? One of the most well loved users of 2013, one of the best strategists, and they let him go unnommed. He Won with 48.3% of the vote)
Stars 268- Shawnpat7 (Won with 35.2% of the vote. Should have been much more as this guy is truly a top tier strategist on this site, and they didn't even see him coming)
Stars 272- Lexxxy (Won with 38.8% of the vote just barely beating out the 2nd place person by .4%)
Stars 273- NexusCain (A no bull shit kinda guy who won with 46.1% of the vote. An amazing game player on the site, not surprised he did it.
Stars 279- #Corey1 (4th time going unnommed was NOT the charm. In the first 18 person stars he went unnommed and surprisingly took 2nd with 22.4% after the smart move of bringing both #Thumper91 and #cfff to finals so that #cfff's and #thumper91's votes would split. Although, #Thumper91 still killed it with 58.4% of the vote.)
Stars 280- asz9191 (after going unnommed, he loses to #BbDamian)
Stars 286- Sweet_Susan (Although not being on much in the beginning, he against all odds made it unnommed in like his 20th stars. He won with 42.0%, beating out the flavor #Meduncan and #Maxi1234)
Who will be next?
Stars 288- vixanu (#Vixanu is robbed of a stars win after playing a spectacular game once again. He loses to the flavor #Bridgette77 who got 42.1% while he settled for 2nd place with 33.8%)
Stars 291- phenomanimal (#Phenomanimal, despite his popularity AND #Thumper91's popularity, he against all odds went unnommed and beat out the most popular person on tengaged with more than 10% getting 47.1% of the vote.)
Stars 298- bb5lover (Being countered 8 times total starting day 1, he controlled the game and had a tight alliance of people who were loyal to him. Every time someone tried to get him out, he got rid of them. This was the best stars player I ever met, nuff said. He finally got his deserved win after going unnommed with 39.6%)
Stars 299- sahmosean (Amazing gameplay, pushing through the game with a tight alliance. At Final 5, 3 people were unnominated, and HE was the one who was able to go unnominated. In the end, he got his deserved win with 40.0%.)
Stars 303- eyoomarcus (Took 2nd place with 36.3% to #clueliz who got 44.9%, the flavor)
Stars 305- mikespike (Won his FIRST stars unnommed with 39.3%)
Stars 306- funnehliner (Underdog unnommed win with 43.6% against one of the most popular people on the site)
Stars 309- kentuckyy (Lost to #Gagaluv instead of winning for the 2nd time 39.1% to 35.0%)
Stars 314- mcbenjamin and ticofernandez (They got what happens to almost everyone who goes unnommed with two people, 2nd and 3rd from votes splitting. #monique90210 got 52.2% of the vote while Tico and Ben settled with 25.1% and 22.7%)
Stars 319- SurvivorFreak13 (Lost to #Carlisle, who lost to #funnehliner the last time someone went unnommed in a Stars he was in finals. Dylan was robbed and got 36.7% of the vote while Carlisle got 39.2%. After running the game and playing great socially and strategically, he still came up short.)
Stars 322- Coreyants (Yeah, that's right fucking Corey won stars before me UNNOMMED with 40.8% of the vote.)
Stars 327- jojo7784 (Biggest fluke Stars win ever, only reason he went unnommed is because everyone thought he was getting algoed but the #randomize added the update. This win shouldn't even be on this list lol. Sorry Jojo but its true :x your win is extremely controversial and you should've gotten 4th-7th place, not an unnommed stars win)
Stars 227- Manda17_xoxo and Bradd156 (Once again, when 2 people go unnommed in the same game their votes split. So #bradd156's 2nd time going unnommed still didn't pay off as he took 3rd, #manda17_xoxo took 2nd, and #Dools won)
lemonfaceemmaleigh went unnommed like 3 times and lost 2 times when she went unnommed. So I think what happened is he kept going unnommed with another person (like 2 or 3 times) and the votes just kept splitting and he kept losing. This just shows that popularity has always been over game play.
not to discredit them but it just seems like going unnommed was a lot more common in the earlier era ... for example since stars 200 13 ppl have done it while 59 ppl were unnommed in the first 100 (which is an avg of more than one per game) and only 23 people in the second 100 game portion ..
alireza1373 I remember stars games back in the day having so many more strategic players. A lot more than you see in stars games today. So that may also be a factor.
This blog is more than a bit presumptuous, going unnommed DOES mean amazing gameplay in some circumstances but not always. to really say that each of these people were "robbed" would be to say that knowing the mechanics of the particular game (which you don't know) and the public opinions of that specific time on tengaged (which, unless you're a multi, you have no way of knowing pre-2010), their strategy to go un-nommed was superior and therefore more deserving of a win.
But then we get into the territory of the conversation: Can it really make sense to SAY that someone who did not win deserved it? The "robbed" people who went unnominated lost their games because they did not acquire enough votes; they weren't deprived of their win by a fluke or a trick, but by failing to measure up on the scale that determines who wins DIRECTLY.
Therefore, I hold that none of these people deserved it, and therefore none were "robbed". Agree with other comments saying going unnommed meant something different in earlier stars. Personally, I feel that going un-nommed is a bit overinflated in current importance. Stars is, at the core, a popularity contest, but many people overcomplicate their votes more now by making assumptions on the game based on very little evidence (the nominations are all we can see) and deeming a person as having played a better game. In this context, going un-nominated is smart, but not infallible; a strong public game is always necessary.
So good on you for collecting on this data, but it annoys that you have the nerve to judge who deserved to win.
mahogany many times going unnominated means the best gameplay, but I agree that quite often it's not (very rare nowadays for someone to go unnommed anyway). The most difficult Stars I ever played was going from 16th to unnominated for the rest of the game.
I was in stars 227 where Those two players went unommed and Dools won. if i'm going to be honest, it wouldn't have mattered if only one of them made it unommed because Dools was going to win no matter what, he was THAT popular! :P
