1. Jenna Lewis (Borneo: 8th, All-Stars: 3rd) - She was only voted off in Borneo because of Sean's alphabetical strategy, and she would've won All-Stars but her foot slipped in the Final Immunity Challenge.
2. Mike Skupin (Australia: 11th) - The first person ever to be removed due to injury. I strongly believe as do many fans that Kucha would have dominated the merge had he not been forced to leave.
3. Paschal English (Marquesas: 4th) - The one and only Purple Rock victim. This was probably one of the most controversial moments in Survivor production history.
4. Wanda Shirk (Palau: 19th/20th) - In another controversial moment, she was eliminated during the school-yard tribe pick. This was completely unfair considering how much of a Survivor fan she is.
5. Rafe Judkins (Guatemala: 3rd) - Okay I know he let himself get eliminated by telling Danni she could vote him out in the Final 3, but I still think that was 38 days of suffering talking, not his actual mind.
6. Terry Deitz (Exile Island: 3rd) - Terry dominated challenges during the merge, and the only vote he ever got was the one Danielle gave him in the Final 3.
7. Michelle Yi (Fiji: 10th) - Michelle's elimination has always bothered me. During the first post-merge Immunity Challenge, the tribe was divided into two teams of five, and only the losing team went to Tribal Council. It wasn't fair that she would've stayed if she hadn't randomly had to go to Tribal Council without the rest of her alliance.
8. Erik Reichenbach (Micronesia: 5th) - I know it was his own fault for stupidly giving up Immunity, but I believe Erik does deserve a chance to try again.
9. Matty Whitmore (Gabon: 4th) - Matty would've won Gabon, but Sugar's emotional connection to Bob forced a tiebreaker in the Final 4, and honestly who could ever beat Bob in a fire-making challenge?
10. Stephen Fishbach (Tocantins: 2nd) - Stephen was forced to remain loyal to his original tribe at the merge since they were the minority, but the unfortunate aspect of that was that Taj and J.T. were both way more likeable than him. If he was on a season where he actually had end-game options, he could win.
11. Marty Piombo (Nicaragua: 11th) - Marty was overly strategic and cocky. If he had the chance to play again I believe he'd be more humble and he would do much better.
12. Jane Bright (Nicaragua: 6th) - Jane was a victim of end-game jury vote paranoia. If she was on a Heroes vs. Villains type season where half of the cast is extremely likeable as opposed to just two people, I think she would have better odds.
13. Holly Hoffman (Nicaragua: 4th) - Fabio's Immunity streak kind of sealed her fate. Similar to Jane, she was too likeable to go to the end with such horrible people like Sash. She did well and she deserves to try again.
14. Ashley Underwood (Redemption Island: 4th) - Ashley did a good job of playing into Rob's power in order to advance. However, I think she let it get away from her and by the end, it was too late to get Rob out. If Ashley had a second chance on a fair playing field (i.e. one without a 4-time All-Star and brain-dead tribemates) she would do well.
15. Andrea Boehlke (Redemption Island: 5th) - Similar to Ashley, Andrea was just a good player caught in the wrong season. Rob was afraid of anyone who was smarter than him, and Andrea was.
16. Brandon Hantz (South Pacific: 6th) - Brandon was young, stupid, and too religious when he played. If he hadn't been in a cult-like alliance with Coach, I guarantee he would've been a smarter player.
17. Troy "Troyzan" Robertson (One World: 8th) - Troyzan was a victim of stupid castmates who were blindly loyal to Kim. He would do better on an All-Stars season where people are more strategically in-tune.
18. Christina Cha (One World: 4th) - People will absolutely disagree with this. I honestly wouldn't have even considered her until after seeing the One World reunion where she was asked about her uselessness. I totally believed her speech about purposely playing dumb because she was surrounded by people who wanted to take out the strong. Her performance in the early episodes where she was trying to make deals with the boys shows that she has it in her to compete well.
Comments
It was confirmed at the reunion that both Rob and Amber woulda beaten Jenna :X
