People who I think would be worthy enough for All-Stars from the first 5 seasons. Not including winners, even though Christine Ha, and probably Luca would be All-Star locks, realistically.
These picks aren't solely based off cooking abilities, but also on how prominent of a character they were on their respective seasons.
SEASON 1
Lee
Sharone
SEASON 2
Christian
Suzy
Ben
Tracy
I would say Adrien but he was rlly boring
SEASON 3
Becky
Frank
Monti
Felix
Ryan
SEASON 4
Natasha
Jessie
Krissi
Lynn
Bime
One of James/Jordan
Possibly Bri
SEASON 5
Elizabeth
Leslie
Willie
Ahran
LIST
Ahran
Becky
Ben
Bime
Christian
Elizabeth
Felix
Frank
Jessie
Krissi
Lee
Leslie
Lynn
Monti
Natasha
Ryan
Sharone
Suzy
Tracy
Willie
SurvivorFreak13 Yeah I don't remember 1-2 as well as 3-5, but I do remember Christian being a giant c*nt on Season 2, Suzy being an overbearing witch, and Ben being the token gay. I only included Tracy b/c she was a really good cook, despite being pretty UTR.