With yet another villain biting the dust with Harley Quinn, Fluttershy gets to spend even more time with Jack Spicer on Redemption Island. Slowly and surely, Jack admits in a confessional that he thinks he is becoming a Brony, but he would never admit it. Jack is soon caught by Fluttershy building a sand-pony on the beach, but he quickly states that it's a war horse and not a pony. Fluttershy admits in a confessional of her own that she doesn't think Jack is as evil as others make him out to be.
When Trixie returns to the Anti-Heroes, Cartman, Roger and Ursala all demand Trixie explain why yet another villain was voted out in Harley Quinn. Trixie makes up a lie that she voted to save Harley Quinn and that Patrick, Pikachu and Yugi were too tight to break up. Trixie says in a confessional that is now 100% with the heroes, and has no problem lying to the villains and leading them down the path of ruin so that they can pay for their rottenness. Be this as it may, Trixie still has fun toying with Batman, Kuki and Omi about being on the fence and not knowing what she was going to do. Kuki attempts to make Trixie's mane pretty for her while she naps, but she instead makes it look awful. Trixie would later accuse Omi of messing up her mane and subsequently buries him in the sand as punishment. Batman is amused.
Over on the Sub-Villains, Sofia thanks the other four players for once again sparing her. While Patrick, Pikachu and Yugi attempt to be nice about it, Kaiba has no problem bluntly stating that if they lose again, she WILL be voted out one way or another and the vote last tribal was just to get the bigger threat out. This leads Sofia to start training on her own and getting prepared for Redemption Island, since she knows that her tribe wasn't about to win another challenge anytime soon.
Indeed, following yet another Anti-Heroes win, it was much of the same. This time around, the Sub-Villains decided to kidnap Omi for a change of pace, while the Anti-Heroes chose to exile Batman...except Batman was on their tribe and they could not do that. Batman is not amused by the amount of stupidity on his tribe, and in turn irritably just sends Patrick Star to Exile Island from the Sub-Villains. This immediately made Sofia realize that she was as good as dead.
As Omi joined up with the Sub-Villains for the night, he immediately (loudly) made it clear that he was voting off a villain and there was no use trying to sway him to do anything else. Since he had immunity, he knew he was safe saying whatever he wanted. Since Kaiba and Sofia were the only two villains left on the tribe, it was clear that Omi would be voting for one of them that night. Even with Patrick out on Exile Island, the Kaiba and Yugi's alliance still had Pikachu, and therefore were unconcerned about whatever Omi decided to do. Against Kaiba's wishes, Yugi went and informed Omi of this alliance, and asked him to please vote with them tonight.
At tribal council, it was mostly uneventful. Sofia didn't even bother to make a plea, since even IF Omi voted for Kaiba instead of her, it wouldn't be enough to sway Pikachu and Yugi's votes. Once more, the vote was unanimous, as Sofia Lamb was finally voted out 4-1 and sent to Redemption Island.
The next day, however, it was revealed that it was time for a merge, and the winner of the three-way duel at Redemption Island would finally be returning to the game. Fluttershy, Jack Spicer and Sofia Lamb all wanted to return to the game for their own reasons, and each gave it their all in their (hopefully) final Redemption Island duel. Sofia, despite training a little in advance, proved to be too spent to go any further and ended up dropping out in 3rd place and getting fully eliminated from the game. This left it down to Fluttershy vs. Jack, both of whom were now secretly friends. Just as it looked like Jack was going to outlast Fluttershy and return, he made a very stupid slip-up and fell out of the running, giving Fluttershy the victory and a shocking return to the game.
20th - Elizabeth Comstock (Bioshock Infinite)
19th - Aria Montgomery (Pretty Little Liars)
18th - Darkrai (Pokemon)
17th - Alison DiLaurentis (Pretty Little Liars)
16th - Mulan (Mulan)
15th - Harley Quinn (Batman)
14th - Sofia Lamb (Bioshock 2)
13th - Jack Spicer (Xiaolin Showdown)
Redemption Island:
Cosmic Warriors Tribe:
Batman (Batman)
Eric Cartman (South Park)
Fluttershy (My Little Pony)
Kuki Sanban (Codename: Kids Next Door)
Omi (Xiaolin Showdown)
Patrick Star (Spongebob)
Pikachu (Pokemon)
Roger Klotz (Doug)
Seto Kaiba (Yu-Gi-Oh)
Trixie (My Little Pony)
Ursala (The Little Mermaid)
Yugi Muto (Yu-Gi-Oh)
As the 12 remaining players merged, it was revealed that Redemption Island would still be in play, as would Exile Island. One immunity idol would be brought back into play, but ONLY on Exile Island. To make things even MORE interesting, two players would be voted out immediately and sent to Redemption Island, along with two players winning immunity. Somehow, Eric Cartman and Roger Klotz both won individual immunity and were safe from the vote. The two players they decided to send to Exile Island would ALSO be safe from the vote.
IMMUNITY WINNERS: Eric Cartman & Roger Klotz
TWO PLAYERS SENT TO EXILE ISLAND:
TWO PLAYERS VOTED OUT:
Fluttershy and Trixie
Two Players Voted Out:
Patrick and Ursula