Things were starting to go according to plan on the island, with the alliance of Cartman, Fluttershy, Kuki, Omi and Trixie making their way to the final five. With Kaiba sent to Redemption Island, Yugi was now pretty much a sitting duck. Would things shake out the way they should?
First, "loves ones" came to the island to participate with the final six and help them in their reward challenge. Stanley Marsh was Eric Cartman's visitor, Rainbow Dash was Fluttershy's visitor, Wallabee Beatles was Kuki Sanban's visitor, Kimiko Tohomiko was Omi's visitor, Twilight Sparkle was Trixie's visitor, and Joey Wheeler was Yugi Muto's visitor. Yugi and Joey won the reward challenge, and selected Cartman and Trixie to spend the day with them. Yugi knew that he had to get at least two of the other players to flip so that he would have a fighting chance at the next tribal council, and since Kuki and Omi were much too strong-willed to ever consider flipping from their allies, and Fluttershy was too fragile to try and manipulate, Yugi had to rely on Cartman and Trixie.
After the reward, and trying to get Cartman and Trixie to flip and join him, Yugi tried his best at the next immunity challenge, but was very upset when the last person he wanted to win immunity got it: Omi. With his intended target now wearing immunity, Yugi was pretty much a sitting duck. Omi sent Fluttershy to Exile Island, so that she wouldn't have to deal with any drama later on, should it come to that. Now out of options, Yugi tried to instead get Cartman and Omi to flip on Trixie, saying that she would likely win the game if she was taken to the end due to how much she's had to endure and fight through.
At tribal council, Yugi played himself up as a worthless pawn that no one would vote for, and voting him out would be pretty much pointless right now, since the other five would have to start picking each other off soon after anyway. Sadly for him, Cartman and Omi refused to flip, and Yugi was sent to Redemption Island to join Kaiba with a 4-1 vote.
On Redemption Island, Kaiba pays no attention to his partner Yugi, and instead only cares about winning so he can reenter the game. At the next challenge, as with all of their previous duels, Yugi once again bests Kaiba and gets first place to stay alive. However, once more, Kaiba refuses to go down without a fight, and finally ousts Pikachu and gets second place. Pikachu becomes the fifth member of the jury, and yet again continues the pattern of hero-villain-hero-villain-hero for jury members.
20th - Elizabeth Comstock (Bioshock Infinite)
19th - Aria Montgomery (Pretty Little Liars)
18th - Darkrai (Pokemon)
17th - Alison DiLaurentis (Pretty Little Liars)
---------Tribe Switch---------
16th - Mulan (Mulan)
15th - Harley Quinn (Batman)
14th - Sofia Lamb (Bioshock 2)
13th - Jack Spicer (Xiaolin Showdown)
---------Merge & Jury---------
12th - Patrick Star (Spongebob)
11th - Roger Klotz (Doug)
10th - Batman (Batman)
9th - Ursala (The Little Mermaid)
8th - Pikachu (Pokemon)
Cosmic Warriors Tribe:
Eric Cartman (South Park)
Fluttershy (My Little Pony)
Kuki Sanban (Codename: Kids Next Door)
Omi (Xiaolin Showdown)
Trixie (My Little Pony)
With all of their targets gone, the final five realized that they now had no choice but to start picking one another off, just like Yugi had warned. While someone WOULD be returning from Redemption Island following the next tribal council, everyone was currently just focused on saving themselves right now. A bit unnerved that Yugi decided to target her at the last tribal, Trixie used this as motivation to get the next immunity win for herself. It was then revealed that Exile Island was no more, and after this vote, someone WOULD be returning from Redemption Island.