Following yet another disgraceful and very embarrassing loss, the Warriors Tribe were feeling less like All-Stars and more like losers. At least everyone except Heather, who had no problem blaming everyone except herself for their continued losses. Colby and Rob had been spared for one vote thanks to the help of Fluttershy and Heather, but weren't sure they could survive another one. That is, until, Heather told them that she would still vote with them and help pick off another girl. If they refused, she would instead get the girls to target one of them. Colby and Rob really had no choice but to comply with Heather's demands.
Knowing they could either target Elissa or Lindsay, Heather asked both Colby and Rob what they felt was best. Rob said that Lindsay could not be underestimated, since the stupid ones always had a way with making it farther than many would expect. Colby said that Elissa was just as likeable, but her being smarter made her an even bigger threat than Lindsay. Fluttershy wasn't even asked an opinion, and felt rather hurt. Colby gave Fluttershy some hugs and cuddles, although admitted in a confessional that he knew all his older friends were going to be taking away his masculinity card after the game.
At tribal council, Elissa tried to rally Fluttershy, Heather and Lindsay to vote out one of the boys, since they were bad luck to the tribe. When asked what she meant, Elissa pointed out that Vecepia and Ann were both voted out back-to-back and it was causing the tribe bad luck thanks to no males leaving. This statement was heavily mocked by Rob. When it came time to voting, Elissa and Lindsay both voted for Colby, but Colby, Fluttershy, Heather and Rob all stayed true to one another and voted out the bigger threat Elissa 4-2.
After losing Elissa, the next challenge would prove to be very bittersweet for the Warriors Tribe. Due to the very rough and physical nature of the challenge, Rob took several more turns when he should've, going up against the likes of Jack, Jim and Russell from the other tribe. Rob eventually went down with a broken leg, but the Warriors Tribe ended up breaking their losing streak and winning immunity. Rob, sadly, was medically evacuated from the game and ineligible to return when the Outcast twist hit. Despite the evacuation, the Amazons Tribe still had to go to tribal council.
