Following Fluttershy's shocking win that very nearly made her faint from excitement and disbelief, it was time for old and new alliances to be put into motion and the craziness of the All-Star merge to commence. Being the only season left without at least three people, both Elissa and Russell from season 2 felt on the outs and in danger. Ursala rounded up her three fellow season 4 players in Fluttershy, Jack and Kuki to work together. Jack refused at first, so Ursala allowed him to think that he was in charge, which made him go with it. Knowing they needed three more votes for majority, they debated between the season 3 players and the season 1 players. Colby, Heather and Lindsay seemed to be the smarter three (Lindsay aside), since the three Tengaged players Jim, Nick Bradley and Nick Newman were sneaky bastards who knew how to manipulate.
While Fluttershy and Kuki worked their adorable charm on Colby and Lindsay, Ursala and Jack tried to persuade Heather to team up with the season 4 players. Jack nearly blew it by acting like an ass, but Ursala assured Heather that she would be at the very top because Fluttershy and Kuki were massive likeable threats to win. When Jack asked why he wasn't a threat to win, Ursala corrected herself by saying that Jack was the "most likely to win the game" and he was "very important" for their game, so he was the "only one" they wanted to keep in the know of their ultimate plans. When Jack flew off to gloat and camera hog a confessional about this, Ursala and Heather had a quick discussion about how Jack was an easy idiot to manipulate.
At tribal council, Fluttershy was asked if she was trying to be more assertive this season, since the reason she lost to Trixie last time was due to not being aggressive enough and relying too heavily on being dragged to the end. She tried to answer, but Heather interrupted her by saying that every champion had to lose once before they could claim what was rightfully theirs, referencing how she lost two seasons of Total Drama before beating Alejandro in Total Drama World Tour. Russell was asked if he felt confident, and he said that he did, because he always felt confident. However, when it came to the vote, it was revealed that he shouldn't have. Colby, Heather and Lindsay all ultimately teamed up with Fluttershy, Jack, Kuki and Ursala and voted out the huge threat Russell Hantz 7-5 over Lindsay, making him the first member of the jury.
With one of the biggest threats out of the game, it was time for another big immunity challenge to try and express dominance at the merge. Fluttershy went from first to worst, but another female ended up taking home individual immunity in her wake: Heather.
I vote to eliminate .......................Ursala