With Jack and Ursala, the two biggest drama-makers now out of the game, Heather felt she could finally take control without any type of real resistance. Making sure to keep the flustered Fluttershy by her side, Heather made sure she was still tight with Elissa, Kuki and Lindsay. The all-female alliance agreed to work together until the end, with Heather privately calling herself the smarter, more ruthless version of Kim Spradlin. The Tengaged boys and Colby felt like something was amiss when most of the girls started to avoid them, so they sent their favorite scapegoat, Nick Bradley, to investigate. Nick approached Lindsay to inquire about any shady dealings going on, knowing Lindsay was stupid and loved to blab, but ended up tripping over a rock and bashing his face into a tree. Lindsay treated his wounds back at camp, while randomly stating through her nonsensical dialogue that her all-female alliance would be wonderful to go to a mall with later. Nick Bradley wanted to go inform the boys about this, but resting on Lindsay's lap and staring up at her breasts while she treated him made him reconsider for a while.
After yet another immunity win for a female (Kuki), Nick Bradley finally remembered his "chat" with Lindsay and warned Colby, Jim and Nick Newman about it. He made sure to leave out the part about him drooling over some big boobies over his head. Realizing they were in huge trouble, Colby and Jim went to Heather to inform her about Lindsay "spilling the beans" and how she's not worth the headache she is putting up with. While Heather agrees with this, she states in a confessional that Lindsay is a loyal number, so she IS worth the headache over the smarter males. Nick Newman attempts to flirt with Lindsay about joining their side, because they'd treat her like a goddess. Lindsay gets confused, because she totally forgot there was two Nicks in the game, so she thought Nick Newman was Nick Bradley. She then wondered if they cloned themselves, which she really wanted to try. She asked Fluttershy if she could help with that, but Fluttershy stated she was a Pegasus, not a unicorn, and could not perform magic. Lindsay was disappointed.
At tribal council, Heather was asked if the women had banded together against the guys, considering how two of the strongest males so far had been taken out and the leader female soon followed. Heather feigned ignorance, and instead "asked" Lindsay if she knew what that meant. Lindsay shook her head and said she "knew better than to reveal our super secret all-female alliance", which just made everyone groan. Jim was bluntly asked which one of the four males were likely in trouble tonight, and he stated himself or Colby, since they were the two strongest males. Nick Bradley takes offense to that, before falling off his seat and nearly falling into the fire. Nick Newman just keeps his mouth shut. When it came to the vote, the scared boys turned on one another just to try and stay alive. The two Nicks voted for Colby, Jim voted for Nick Bradley, and Colby voted for Jim. However, the five girls all voted for Colby, sending the Survivor threat to the jury in a 7-1-1 vote.
With the boys now in panic mode, they knew it was pretty much win immunity or go home. But it was time for a double-elimination, and things didn't seem to get any better. The first immunity winner turned out to be a female again, another shocking win for Fluttershy, who was slowly starting to gain more and more confident. However, the biggest shock of the night came when klutzy dimwit and love interest of Lindsay, Nick Bradley, pulled out the second immunity win. A male FINALLY won immunity.
IMMUNITY WINNERS: Fluttershy & Nick Bradley
VOTE OUT TWO PLAYERS FROM THE MERGED GALAXY TRIBE!
