With the writing on the wall, the final three males of the game, all All-Star Tengaged boys, knew that they were pretty much sunk. No matter how much Jim and Nick Newman talked to any of the girls, they were standing firm in their all-girls alliance and refused to budge. Even Fluttershy and Kuki refused to listen to anything the guys said, since none of the girls had given any of them reason to doubt their intentions, while the males have. However, Nick Bradley continued to endear himself to Lindsay, unbeknownst to anyone else. Nick Bradley's latest showcase of making a fool of himself came when he fell asleep on the beach without a chair or blanket, and was woken up when hermit crabs crawled up into his shorts and began to snap not only his butt, but his man region as well. The crazy dance and yelling he put on made Lindsay giggle while she watched from a distance.
Following Fluttershy winning immunity, the other four girls all tried to snag the second one, but was dumbfounded when clumsy Nick Bradley got it instead. When he cheered about his victory, he slipped off the dock where the challenge took place and fell into the water, making Lindsay laugh even more. Back at camp, Jim and Nick Newman were both doomed and they knew it. They tried one last time to talk with Elissa and Heather, the two smartest girls, but were effectively shut down by both. They each tried to find the merge idol, but neither one could, making them incredibly frustrated and angry. Jim angrily told off the girls that making an All-Stars turn out a final five that was all females was embarrassing and rather sexist. Elissa retorted that he was being sexist for saying such a thing. Nearby, after Nick Bradley shook a tree and dropped a few coconuts right on his head, he knocked himself out and was found by Lindsay. She gave him a quick kiss on the cheek, before dragging him into the bushes and happily taking back the coconuts that he had knocked down for himself.
At tribal council, Jim did everything he could to blow things up. He tried throwing Elissa and Heather under the bus for being evil masterminds, he tried insulting Fluttershy to make her cry and hopefully screw with her voting, he tried bribing Kuki by saying he'd give her a truckload of candy if she voted with him, and he tried playing reverse psychology with Lindsay. None of it seemed to work, although it was getting the sore Nick Bradley to laugh, and even Nick Newman was embarrassed by this display. Heather effectively called Jim the Troyzan of the season, which Jim took offense to. When it came to the vote, Jim was punished first for being a fool, and was sent to the jury in a unanimous 7-1 vote, since Nick Newman and Nick Bradley knew it was pointless to vote for anyone else. Right after that, Nick Bradley became the last Nick on the island when Nick Newman was voted out 6-1 and sent to the jury right after his good buddy Jim. This left us with five females and one male.
With Nick Bradley being the only male left, which some people could argue that he was 'lucky' in a certain sense, he did everything his klutzy body could do to win immunity. Shockingly, that's JUST what he did! Much to Heather's disbelief, Nick Bradley pulled off his second straight individual immunity to give himself another three days.