After his new girlfriend won immunity over him, Nick Bradley shocked all the girls by pulling out his hidden immunity idol that he had found right when the teams had merged into one. He announced that he would definitely be playing it on himself tonight, since he's not an idiot and he's not walking away with a souvenir in his pocket, so anything the girls tried to say to him would fall on deaf ears. This immediately began to scare Fluttershy and Kuki, but it just infuriated Heather. Knowing that her plans to sit at the end with two idiots (Fluttershy and Kuki) were now dead, due to Lindsay winning immunity and Nick Bradley flaunting his idol, she now had to turn on either Fluttershy or Kuki. Heather had to think long and hard between which girl couldn't possibly beat her in final immunity, but also which one she could beat in the final three. She was struggling to come up with a decision, since Fluttershy was pretty much loved by everyone (who had a heart and didn't just hate ponies for no logical reason), and Kuki was a spirited young girl who could win over anyone's heart with her giggly personality.
Fluttershy, Kuki and Lindsay meanwhile all had a conversation about possibly voting out Heather once and for all, since she was really the only mean person left in the game, and all three of them didn't like her. Fluttershy and Kuki both came away from the conversation deciding to vote for Heather, but Lindsay wanted to ask Nick's opinion first, since she felt he could tell her something that only a non-pony and non-kid could. After sharing another passionate kiss (in private), Nick explained to Lindsay that it would be best to keep Heather around because most of the jury were males and would not vote for her. Plus, she was pretty hated all-around. So it would be in their best interest to take out a threat to win the game in either Fluttershy or Kuki. They just had to figure out which one. Lindsay felt really sad to do this, but after hitting her head a few times to make sure her brain was working, she realized Nick was right.
At tribal council, Nick Bradley openly wore his idol around his neck, shocking most all the members on the jury. When Nick was asked if there was a 100% chance he was playing it on himself, he said yes. He said that girls were unpredictable and you couldn't always trust them. Plus, he didn't want to be another Erik. When Heather was asked who she targets then between the only two possible players NOT protected (other than herself), Fluttershy and Kuki, Heather said that the vote could make her or break her. Heather recalls back to Total Drama Island, when she lost in the final three and the winner turned out to be the most likeable person in the cast, Owen, and how he is similar to both Fluttershy and Kuki. When it came time to vote, both Fluttershy and Kuki stuck with voting for Heather. Heather decided to pick Fluttershy, but both Lindsay and Nick voted for Kuki. Nick played his idol, but no votes were cast for him. This wound up creating a 2-2-1 tie between Heather and Kuki. They had a re-vote, and both Heather and Kuki could not vote. Although Kuki pleaded for Lindsay and Nick to change their minds, neither one did. Fluttershy refused to betray Kuki, but Lindsay and Nick both voted her out 2-1 on the re-vote, sending Kuki to the jury.
Finally down to the last individual immunity challenge, the four finalists all gave it everything they had to sit in the finale of the amazing All-Star season. Fluttershy fell out of it quickly, while Lindsay got lost along the halfway point. Heather and Nick both battled right to the end, before Nick continued his impressive run as the last male standing to snag victory just seconds before Heather, winning the final immunity and securing him a place in the final three.
