Coming to the conclusion of one of the craziest seasons yet in the illustrious series of Total Drama Survivor Crossover, it came down to three All-Stars. One represented season 1, one represented season 3, and one represented season 4. A jury containing five males and four females all had interesting words to say to the finalists.
Russell, being new to the whole 'being on the jury' aspect, pretty much called Lindsay a stupid bimbo bitch and Fluttershy a pathetic little coattail-rider. He called Nick a sorry excuse for a man, but said he had worked a bit harder than the other two, so he had his vote.
Jack openly mocked Lindsay and laughed at her, and then told Fluttershy she should just go home and play with her animals already. Jack then commented that Nick had the potential to be evil and he should give him a call sometime, to which Nick did not know how to respond to.
Ursala completely ignored Fluttershy while asking Lindsay and Nick to defend each of their games on its own merit without putting either of them into the equation. After the answers, Ursala felt that even though Lindsay acted stupid, there was a lot more to her.
Colby commended the three finalists for all reaching the end, and started by saying that while he loved Fluttershy as a girl, he couldn't in all seriousness vote for her. He then asked Lindsay why she played better than Nick, since he was the last male standing.
Jim chose to ignore both Fluttershy and Lindsay and just focused on Nick. He both insulted and praised Nick at the same time. He insulted him for backstabbing him and Nick Newman just to save his own butt, but then complimented him for outwitting all the remaining girls to make the end.
Nick Newman scolded Lindsay for thinking he was a clone of Nick Bradley, claiming that he was by far the sexier Nick and the smarter one. Nick Bradley then asked if Nick Newman was so smart, why didn't he make the end. Nick Newman pretty much didn't have an answer for that.
Elissa politely asked each finalist why she should vote for them, before explaining that Fluttershy pretty much (once again) did nothing the whole game, while Nick pretty much just got lucky to make the end rather than actually be strategic. Lindsay wondered if that meant she would vote for her.
Kuki yelled at Lindsay and Nick for voting her out over Heather, and asked them why they did it. They each explained that Kuki was a very likeable threat to win and they felt it was the best move. Kuki then asked why they allowed Fluttershy to make it that far then.
Heather went on a tirade on her turn, giving a long speech about how she was robbed yet again and how she deserved to be in the finale instead of the three finalists. She openly insulted Fluttershy for being pathetic, and insulted Lindsay even worse for proving to be disloyal. Even though he was a guy, Heather appreciated Nick the most.
Ultimately, it was time for the jury to make a decision. Just like in season 4, Fluttershy was viewed as a nice pony by most everybody, but yet again she was heavily criticized for never stepping out of her comfort zone to actually make a move on her own during the game, and voting for somebody just based on their level of kindness wasn't right. Lindsay was the most polarizing of the finalists, as half of the jury felt that she was a nice girl who's dumbness and idiocy actually was an asset instead of a weakness, while the other half felt she was nothing more than a lucky moron who was in the right place at the right time. Nick, being the only male left, was praised for managing to outlast all the women to make the final three, and for winning a few immunities along with finding two idols. However, he was criticized as well for acting stupid and klutzy most of the time, and people were almost comparing him to Fabio. The votes would prove that this season was going to go right down to the wire with its craziness:
Russell - NICK (As usual, he didn't want to give any female any validation, and felt that Nick made the boys proud)
Jack - NICK (He felt like voting for Fluttershy just for the laughs, but ultimately wised up and voted for his best player)
Ursala - LINDSAY (Respected Lindsay for outlasting Heather and being the cause of her elimination)
Colby - LINDSAY (He didn't want to be considered sexist and hold a grudge, and he felt Lindsay really did play well)
Jim - NICK (Wanting to give Tengaged their first winner in the series, and he really did feel like Nick played great)
Nick Newman - NICK (Although still feeling humiliated that a Nick was voting for a Nick, he knew that he played the best)
Elissa - LINDSAY (She liked Lindsay's positive attitude and was glad she was the only female to really get a male to take her to the end)
Kuki - FLUTTERSHY (She didn't want to vote for an adult or a teenager who hurt her, and she loved Fluttershy a lot)
Heather - NICK (She would never vote for Lindsay, and she felt that Fluttershy was a joke, so this was the only logical conclusion)
In a 5-3-1 vote, NICK BRADLEY WINS TOTAL DRAMA SURVIVOR CROSSOVER: ALL-STARS!
