JILLIAN HAD A HORRIBLE SOCIAL GAME. EMMETT WAS GOING TO BEAT GARY 6-1. JILLIAN /LOST/ 4-3 BECAUSE SHE WENT BACK ON TOO MANY DEALS, AND LIED UNECESSARILY LIKE NATALIE MARTINEZ. EMMETT & JILLIAN BOTH WON ABOUT THE SAME AMOUNT OF COMPS, AND PLAYED A SIMILAR STRATEGIC GAME, EXCEPT EMMETT WAS MORE LIKABLE, AND DIDN'T LIE LEFT & RIGHT FOR NO REASON LIKE JILLIAN, WHICH IS WHY HE WOULD'VE BEATEN GARY AND WHY SHE /LOST/ TO GARY.
THERE'S NO SUCH THING AS ___ DESERVED TO WIN IF THEY CAN'T WIN THE JURY OVER. AND SHE DIDN'T WIN THE JURY OVER.
END OF STORY.
YOU CAN LEAVE ALL OF YOUR CRY BABY "GARY RETURNED NOT FAIR!!!111" SHIT AT HOME, ACTING LIKE HE WAS GIVEN A SPOT IN THE FINAL 2. NO, HE EARNED HIS SPOT BY WINNING A VETO, MAKING A DEAL WITH EMMETT TO SAVE HIMSELF OVER TALLA, AND WINNING FINAL HOH. BYE.
I see what people mean now when they tell me "you can't say one winner is better than another, its about your personal preference" like obscurity does.
I personally would NEVER vote for someone who was once evicted like Gary regardless of how sloppily the other person played. I just don't think if you get out you deserve a second chance.
yts1 aka aquamarine I'm FINE with the thought of not wanting someone to win if they got a second chance. But I usually get mad when people say that, because 98% of people who say Gary didn't deserve a second chance rooted for Nicole to win BB16.
I get what you mean, by saying the best player was the one that wasn't evicted. I totally get it. But I personally don't care, at that point IMO it's about making the jury want to give you the win, and if the majority want you to win, you deserved the win.
She didn't win the jury over because THEY WERE BITTER. I'm not saying Gary should have lost because he returned. What I am saying is Jillian played a better game than Gary did so she deserved to win.
Joel_n I see what you're saying about playing the better game to get to the END. But she MADE the jury bitter, which would never make them vote for her, even up against someone who returned.
Oh believe me Timster I didn't want Nicole to win either. I was rooting for Jocasta to re-enter just because it would have been fun to watch how far she could float. I never think the person who re-enters is worthy of winning so I just root for whoever I think would be the most entertaining to re-enter. It's why I HATED Judd coming back.
