I am taking into account the difficulty of the season, the players they versed, their ability to win immunities and whether or not the season was entertaining.
1. Parvati
2. Sandra - HvV
3. J.t
4.Todd
5. Tom
6. Kim
7. Chris
8. Rob
9. Richard
10. Tina
11. Denise
12. Sandra Pearl Islands
13. Brian
14. Cochran
15. Jenna
16. Aras
17. Fabio
18. Vecepia
19. Daani
20. Ethan
21. Bob
22. Sophie
23. Yul
24. Natalie
25. Amber
26. Earl
^WTF? He won by a unanimous vote. Earl is one of the greatest winners ever.
1. Parvati
^WTF? I'm a massive Parvati fan, but she played a terrible game in Micronesia. The only reason she won the season was because James was medically evacuated which meant they have an 8-person Jury in case James was unable to attend the Final Tribal Council. Had Parvati reached the F3 with Cirie and Amanda, like she intended, she would have not stood a chance in winning.
cats3 I agree with Sandra's PI win being more impressive.
Yul got lucky and deserves his spot down there.
I would move Amber up, she had to deal with one of the worst tribe swaps... which Rob saved her from (which he wouldn't have done if he wasn't in her back pocket).
I would move Jenna down, she didn't do much for herself except win the last couple immunities. People like Aras, Vecepia and Ethan played much better games all around.
Rob, Amber, Cochran and Parvati should be bottom 8 because they didn't win their first time. We can argue that Amber and Parvati should be higher because producers tried to screw Amber with the f10 switch and Parvati was effed by the bottle twist and invincible idol, but still.
overrated
jt
denise
cochran
fabio
parvati in micronesia (she got lucky and amanda played better had to do more, she was great in heroes and villains tho and would be top for that game)
sandra (hvv she got lucky, but still a deserving winner. I think parvati should have won that season tho i love sassy sandra)
underrated
heidik
aras
vecepia
yul
earl
natalie (her social game and move at f12 to blindside erik)
amber (it wasn't just rob, she had to convince kathy and shii ann to vote jerri out over her, plus probs one of the best ftc performance)
sophie (played coach and albert so hard)
Kantus I don't see why that would matter. If you're ranking the winners, then you should be ranking their winning season. In which case the bottle twist wasn't in Parvati's winning season. That would actually be a knock against Yul, which is understandable.
