What if Kass didn't flip the merge episode of Cagayan? Assuming they Pagonged the Brawn alliance, let's see what would've happened.
Final 6
Jeremiah
Kass
Morgan
Sarah
Spencer
Tasha
Immunity (random.org): Tasha
Immunity Idol (random.org): Morgan (lol)
Spencer/Tasha are a clear bond, and they try to rake Morgan in as a final 3 goat. Sarah and Kass, who have a strong disdain for eachother finally try to take each other out, and Tasha/Spencer/Jeremiah/Morgan all take Sarah's side, as Kass was perceived as a strategic threat.
Final 5
Jeremiah
Morgan
Sarah
Spencer
Tasha
Immunity (random.org): Jeremiah
Jeremiah/Sarah see the alliance of 3, but it is too late, Spencer/Tasha/Morgan pick Sarah off, and Morgan plays her idol.
Final 4
Jeremiah
Morgan
Spencer
Tasha
Immunity (random.org): Jeremiah
The alliance of 3 implodes on itself. It's a unanimous Spencer vote out, because they think he would win in the end. (Same placement, lol)
Final 3
Jeremiah
Morgan
Tasha
Immunity (random.org): Tasha
Tasha wins immunity and votes Jeremiah out, taking Morgan to the end.
Final 2
Morgan
Tasha
Tasha gets all of the votes to win, and is crowned champ of Survivor: Cagayan.
What Survivor: What If? should I do next, let me know!
Do the merge of Fiji if the twist at the beginning of the merge didn't happen