Men:
1. Lex van den Berghe - Survivor: Africa, 3rd Place; Survivor: All Stars, 9th Place
2. Sean Rector - Survivor: Marquesas, 5th Place
3. Cliff Robinson - Survivor: Cagayan, 14th Place
4. Jay Byars - Survivor: One World, 10th Place
5. Colton Cumbie - Survivor: One World, 13th Place; Survivor: Blood vs. Water, 19th Place
6. Randy Bailey - Survivor: Gabon, 8th Place; Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains, 18th Place
7. Spencer Bledsoe - Survivor: Cagayan, 4th Place; Survivor: Cambodia, 2nd Place
8. Rob Mariano - Survivor: Marquesas, 10th Place; Survivor: All Stars, 2nd Place; Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains, 13th Place; Survivor: Redemption Island, 1st Place
9. John Cochran - Survivor: South Pacific, 8th Place; Survivor: Caramoan, 1st Place
Women:
1. Kim Mullen - Survivor: Palau, 15th Place
2. Nina Poersch - Survivor: Worlds Apart, 16th Place
3. Jolanda Jones - Survivor: Palau, 18th Place
4. Becky Lee - Survivor: Cook Islands, 3rd Place
5. Shirin Oskooi - Survivor: Worlds Apart, 8th Place; Survivor: Cambodia, 19th Place
6. Natalie Anderson - Survivor: San Juan del Sur, 1st Place
7. Alecia Holden - Survivor: Kaoh Rong, 14th Place
8. Tina Scheer - Survivor: Panama, 16th Place
9. Lisa Whelchel - Survivor: Philippines, 2nd Place