A new blog series that I'll never finish (it's the survivornerd way) where I take random HGs out of ANY season and I see what it'd be like if the casts were shuffled around, until we complete Big Brother 19. Ladies and gentleman, the cast of Big Brother 1: Rewriting History!
Firstly, the exes (obviously they aren't real exes, I had to get creative):
Clay Honeycutt & April Lewis
Will Kirby & Lisa Donahue
Alison Irwin & Jase Wirey
Casey Turner & Bridgette Dunning
Matthew Clines & Brittany Martinez
And now for the 3 without exes:
Beau Beasley
Jerry MacDonald
Shelby Stockton
Week 1
Matt won the first HoH of the summer! Right off the bat, he is threatened by Clay, who seems like a competition threat and Will, who seems smarter than everyone else in the house. He sees Casey and Jerry both as perfect pawns. He decides to put up Will next to Jerry.
Jase wins the Power of Veto! In order to not disturb the peace, Jase decides to keep any blood off of his hands and he doesn't use the PoV.
The lady exes tried to get an alliance going with Lisa, Brittany, April, Alison, and Bridgette. Bridgette, however, doesn't hate her ex Casey unlike the others and may even try to work with him. Jerry is getting on everyone's nerves where as Will is seemingly a cool dude, albeit vain, but not very threatening.
Beau votes to evict Jerry.
Jase votes to evict Jerry.
Shelby votes to evict Jerry.
Lisa votes to evict Dr. Will.
Clay votes to evict Jerry.
Bridgette votes to evict Jerry.
Casey votes to evict Jerry.
Brittany votes to evict Dr. Will.
April votes to evict Dr. Will.
Alison votes to evict Dr. Will.
By a vote of 6-4...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Jerry has been evicted from the Big Brother house.
Week 2
Clay won the second HoH of the season. He considered targetting who seemed like the leaders of the X Lady alliance, Lisa or Alison. He also saw Matt as a big physical and social threat, and they never really hit it off. Clay considered Shelby as a pawn, but ended up putting Matt and Alison up.
Matt wins the Power of Veto! Matt obviously uses the Power of Veto on himself. This leaves Clay to choose a replacement nominee. Clay decides to target the X Lady alliance once again and he puts Brittany up on the block next to Alison.
Lisa and April had thought about who they'd save and they decided that Alison was more valuable to their alliance so they voted to evict Brittany. Matt still had beef with Brittany, so he easily voted to evict her. However, a lot of the other houseguests found Alison to be a more threatening competitor.
Lisa votes to evict Brittany.
Beau votes to evict Alison.
Jase votes to evict Alison.
Bridgette votes to evict Alison.
April votes to evict Brittany.
Dr. Will votes to evict Alison.
Shelby votes to evict Alison.
Matt votes to evict Brittany.
Casey votes to evict Alison.
By a vote of 6-3...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Alison has been evicted from the Big Brother house.
Week 3
Brittany wins the Head of Household, doing a complete 180 from being on the block. She recognized that Lisa and April voted against her and decided that they didn't have her back. She also was weary of Matt because he still held a grudge against her. Although she considered people like Jase, a competition threat, or Shelby, a good pawn and a good social player, she decided to put Matt and Lisa up on the block.
Clay wins the Power of Veto! Jase reaches a certain level of annoyingness to the point where Clay goes up to Brittany's HoH room and she wants him to use it so she can backdoor him. When Brittany says she'll do it, Clay gets the idea to strike a deal with Matt. Since Clay saves Matt, Matt would have his back later on in the game as well. At the veto ceremony Clay vetoes Matt, and Brittany blindsides Jase by putting him up on the block.
Matt figures that Jase is the plan and wants to vote to evict him, as well as Bridgette who has very low tolerance for his aggressive behavior, as well as Shelby and Beau. Will on the other hand still has beef with Lisa and casts his vote against her. Clay and Casey see Lisa as a bigger threat to their games than Jase, and April wants to cut all ties from the X Lady alliance as that is a sinking ship.
Casey votes to evict Lisa.
Bridgette votes to evict Jase.
April votes to evict Lisa.
Shelby votes to evict Jase.
Beau votes to evict Jase.
Clay votes to evict Lisa.
Dr. Will votes to evict Lisa.
Matt votes to evict Jase.
There's a 4-4 tie, leaving Brittany to break it. Although she put up Jase because she thought it was what the house wanted, she decides to take action on the very people who turned on her. Brittany votes to evict...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Lisa, she's been evicted from the Big Brother house.
Week 4
Jase wins the HoH competition right after barely surviving the block last week. He sees that people like Shelby and Bridgette voted against him, but he decided to go after the two Xs that conspired against him: Matt and Brittany. And he puts them both on the block.
Matt wins the Power of Veto! Obviously he saves himself, making Jase renominate another person for eviction. Jase puts someone else who voted against him, Beau, up on the block next to Brittany.
Clay and Matt form a pact to help each other get rid of each other's Xs, and work together. Obviously this means that this round they'd go after Brittany. Casey, April, and Shelby all knew that Brittany wouldn't be coming for them so they saw an advantage in keeping her in the game. This left Bridgette and Dr. Will as the swing votes.
April votes to evict Beau.
Shelby votes to evict Beau.
Dr. Will votes to evict Brittany.
Clay votes to evict Brittany.
Matt votes to evict Brittany.
Bridgette votes to evict Brittany.
Clay votes to evict Beau.
By a vote of 4-3...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Brittany has been evicted from the Big Brother house.
Week 5
Matt continues his competition beasting with another HoH win. With his X finally gone he could go after anyone remaining in the game. He considered going for his pal's X April, but he decided that there were bigger fish to fry in Will, due to his great social game, and Jase, due to his challenge wins.
Matt dominates even more with a Power of Veto win. He likes the nominations the way they are so he keeps them the same.
Beau and Shelby, the two remaining non-exes both saw that Jase was coming for them, so they worked together and voted for him. However on this vote, exes April and Clay came together as well as Casey and Bridgette and they gunned for the strongest player socially, and potentially created a new alliance.
Bridgette votes to evict Dr. Will.
Clay votes to evict Dr. Will.
Shelby votes to evict Jase.
Casey votes to evict Dr. Will.
Beau votes to evict Jase.
April votes to evict Dr. Will.
By a vote of 4-2...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Dr. Will has been evicted from the Big Brother house.
Week 6
Shelby wins her first HoH! Since no one is quite sure where her head is at gamewise, this week should be an eye opener. She wants to see such a big physical threat gone in Matt, but she also thinks that if Jase won any power she'd be on the block, so she targets him along with April as her pawn.
Bridgette wins the Power of Veto! Bridgette, although she voted with April, doesn't have a great connection with either HouseGuest so she doesn't use it.
Bridgette and Casey officially decide to work together in the game, but romance wise they are totally off. Matt wants to take out Jase since he's one of the only ones left who can put up a fight against him in challenges, and Beau sees him as someone he can't trust. Clay has been back and forth, but he's finally decided it's best for his game if April leaves the house. This leaves Bridgette and Casey in the middle.
Casey votes to evict April.
Bridgette votes to evict April.
Beau votes to evict Jase.
Matt votes to evict Jase.
Clay votes to evict April.
By a vote of 3-2...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
April has been evicted from the Big Brother house.
Week 7
Bridgette wins her first HoH of the summer! She decides it's best to keep Jase in the house since he'll go after people other than herself, and she thinks Shelby is a perfect, likable pawn, and Matt is her target since he's been steamrolling competitions, so she put those two up.
Bridgette wins the Power of Veto! She still supports her original nominations so she doesn't use it.
Beau and Casey start to think that Matt will go after Jase and Clay as opposed to them, so they try to evict Shelby. Jase and Clay have similar thinking and those two try to start working together to get Matt out.
Beau votes to evict Shelby.
Casey votes to evict Shelby.
Jase votes to evict Matt.
Clay votes to evict Matt.
There's a 2-2 tie, and Bridgette must break it. Bridgette wants to oust her target still, so she votes to evict...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Matt, Matt has been evicted from the Big Brother house.
Week 8
Shelby wins another HoH! Shelby sees the three biggest competitors as Bridgette, Clay, and Jase, and Clay went to her and striked her a deal saying that if she kept him safe, he'd keep her safe. Shelby put up Jase, a loose cannon who would put her up, and Bridgette, a sound player socially but also a player who can win competitions.
Beau wins the Power of Veto! Beau sees the threats on the block and doesn't want to stir the pot, so he doesn't use the Power of Veto.
Clay wants to keep his allegiance to Jase, but Beau obviously is intent on evicting Jase since Jase and Beau are at each other's throats in the game. Casey considers going back on his alliance with Bridgette since she is playing a winner's game.
Casey votes to evict Bridgette.
Beau votes to evict Jase.
Clay votes to evict Bridgette.
By a vote of 2-1...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Bridgette has been evicted from the Big Brother house.
Week 9
Jase wins HoH! He goes from off the block to up in the HoH suite. He puts up the two that have been after him the whole game, even if they aren't huge physical threats, Beau and Shelby.
Shelby wins the Power of Veto! Obviously she uses it on herself, forcing Jase to put up a replacement nominee. Jase stays true to his alliance with Clay and puts Casey up against Beau.
Shelby and Beau have a good alliance going that nobody really knew about because Shelby and Beau have been under the radar for so long. Clay sees Casey as a bigger threat than Beau.
Clay votes to evict Casey.
Shelby votes to evict Casey.
By a vote of 2-0...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Casey has been evicted from the Big Brother house.
Week 10
Clay wins the final 4 HoH. He sticks true to his alliance with Jase and goes after the under the radar players, Beau and Shelby.
Shelby wins the Power of Veto! Meaning she's safe, but she also will cast the sole vote to evict against either Beau or Jase. It's a pretty simple decision for her, Shelby votes to evict...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Jase, Jase has been evicted from the Big Brother house.
Final HoH
Shelby wins part 1 of the first HoH. Between Clay and Beau, the winner of part 2 is...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Clay. Shelby and Clay have a final showdown to see who the final HoH is. The winner of part 3 is...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Clay. Clay could vote Shelby out since she's more deserving but Clay thinks that Beau hasn't done anything to earn the money at all, so he votes to evict him, leaving just Clay and Shelby to battle it out for the 500,000 dollar prize. Most were happy with Shelby's under the radar, no backstabs game, as well as her impressive challenge performance.
Beau votes for Shelby to win.
Dr. Will votes for Shelby to win.
Casey votes for Shelby to win.
Jase votes for Shelby to win.
Bridgette votes for Clay to win.
Matt votes for Clay to win.
April votes for Shelby to win.
By a vote of 5-2, the winner of Big Brother 4: Rewriting History is...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
