JERRI MANTHEY
Australian Outback- 8th (6-2)
All-Stars- 10th (4-1)
Heroes VS Villains- 4th (3-1)
Considered a ‘bitch’ the first time around, she came back for a second go and didn’t really have a great time either and we potentially saw the end of Jerri and her Survivor career. But a third time around in Heroes vs Villains was a revelation for Jerri, as she became a crucial vote in pretty much every tribal council and came so agonisingly close to an appearance at the final tribal council by going out in 4th place. Outside the game she has become one of the most recognisable faces from the game and deserves a spot on this list!
Jerri wasn't a great player. She was just riding coattails in Heroes vs Villains, barely made the jury in Australia, and didn't even get to the merge on All-Stars.