Casting was hard, especially due to some people playing multiple times, unfortunately I could only pick so many. Here is the cast for Heroes vs Villains, the results should be posted in a day or two.
Heroes:
muffinman: 1st (Season 1): he was the first winner, and thus an obvious choice for All Stars. Despite starting the game with no alliances, being the 3rd most strategic and winning the final immunity challenge allowed him underdog his way to a win.
Pukai : 2nd (tied) (Season 1): He was sitting pretty in a four person alliance that dominated the early stages of the game, but thanks to Kaushal that alliance was taken out by mid-merge. Pukai made it to the finals by saving himself with two idols, and even got Kaushal to play one on him.
#parkerstack7 : 1st (Season 2): parkerstack played his idol at the iconic first tribal council of the season, in which he received every vote, yet went on to win the game. He was in the minority for the entirety of the merge, but thanks to 5 immunity wins made it to the end and won.
ForYouSelena : 7th (Season 2): Selena was in the majority alliance, and played a clean game making few enemies, earning Fan Favorite. However, she was eliminated by her own alliance in the final 7.
Elestic 2nd (Season 3): Elestic was in a solid position, until both of his allies were blindsided by Boris. Despite being in a horrible spot, Elestic managed to strategize his way to the end, as #1 most strategic.
LoveMeLoveMe 5th (Season 4): LoveMeLoveMe was an obvious All Star candidate, returning twice from redemption island. Ultimately though, she was picked off by a relentless Zapatera alliance.
Darriusdabest 6th (Season 5): Poor Darrius, as the 3rd most strategic player, he saw the threat that of the four person alliance (led by the rawr, #1 most strategic player) on his tribe, and tried numerous times to take them out. He outlived 2 of them, but he was taken out for 6th, and his worse nightmare came true when rawr went on to win the game. He did earn fan favorite though, solidifying his return as a hero.
Carlisle 2nd (tied) (Season 6): Carlisle was an underdog, having his tribe diminished down to 2 members. However, he was able to make it to the end of the game, thanks to strategic abilities (#1 strategist). However, he made the noble yet foolish decision of taking NewNightmare, the only survivor from his tribe and 3-time immunity winner to the end.
ivan1234 11th (Season 6): Ivan was one of the few people from his original tribe playing the game from the start, working closely with his right hand man brenelle. However, brenelle was idoled out, and Carlisle flipped on him at the merge, taking him out in a 6-5 vote.
MasterB 8th (Season 7): MasterB's Manono tribe lost every single challenge premerge, and 2 former Manono's were lost after the tribe switch as well. MasterB tried valiantly as the last surviving member of his tribe, but suffered a heartbreaking defeat in the final 8.
Villains:
#Kaushal : 6th (Season 1): He was always in the minority in the tribe stage of the game, but he made it deep into the merge by flipping back and forth between his own tribe (which was dominated by a rival alliance of 4) and the other tribe. He won 3 immunity challenges, but ultimately his run was cut short.
Willie_ : 4th (Season 1): Willie was like a Brantsteele version of Russel Hantz. He found two idols, and never needed them. He flipped on his premerge rival Amnesia after the tribe switch, then flipped on his own tribe in the final 10 to avoid a tie. He made it to the final 4, but Pukai decided to send him into a fire-making tie breaker which he lost.
Snake : 2nd (Season 2): Snake lived up to his name and controlled most of the game. He momentarily lost control in the final 6, but adamsel saved him with his idol. Snake returned the favor by voting him out in the next tribal council. Snake made it to the finals, but never stood a chance against a huge underdog like parker.
borisXborisette 6th (Season 3): Boris was a volatile player, sometimes making big moves and sometimes voting in the minority. Boris's downfall was not playing his idol in the final 6, his arrogance caused him to be blindsided and eliminated.
Cromatique 1st (Season 4): Cromatique led an alliance of 5 that brutally and efficiently took out all competition, even blindsiding an idol holder premerge. Cromatique's alliance systematically eliminated all underdogs and fan favorites in their path.
Redthings556 12th (Season 4): Redthings controlled Omepe premerge, but a Zapatera alliance with superior numbers gave him a taste of his own medicine.
AlanDuncan 7th (Season 5): Alan played an aggressive game, effectively serving as his alliance's meatshield. His high-profile gameplay cost him when 2Beastly played an idol to take him out.
2Beastly 3rd (Season 5): 2Beastly had the game in the bag, he eliminated several big players, and his alliance of 3 made it to the final 4. However, he turned against his loyal ally iamrobot, taking rawr to the end and giving him the win.
Whoa 4th (Season 7): Whoa wielded a large amount of power early merge, picking off the remaining Manonos and blindsiding rival Salanis as well. His influence greatly decreased in the final 7, when the Salani outsiders let by DumbGinger turned against his alliance. Whoa went on an immunity streak, but fell short in the final 4.
DumbGinger 5th (Season 7): Dumb Ginger played a sneaky game, orchestrating a major blindside and making it to the final 5 despite starting the game with no alliances. Others eventually caught on though, and he was eliminated in the final 5.
