1. Mr. Wesley

- Killed by: Unknown man

- Cause of death: Knife stabbed through his throat

Mr. Wesley was the principal of Wilson High in 2007. He was invited back to host the 10 year reunion. During setup, he stepped out to take a smoke break. However, he was met outside by a mysterious man in all black who swiftly stuck a dagger clean through Mr. Wesley's throat. With no time to struggle or fight back, Mr. Wesley quickly died.

2. Ruth Bailey

- Killed by: Unknown man

- Cause of death: Head repeatedly bashed against the floor

Ruth, suffering from overwhelming social anxiety, retreated into the girl's bathroom to calm herself down. Unfortunately, it was not the same bathroom Lia was in, so Ruth found herself alone. After suffering from a panic attack due to her phobia of blood being triggered by seeing specks of blood on the sink, Ruth began to panic. While trying to leave, she found herself face to face with the masked man, who grabbed her by the hair, smashed her head against the corner of the sink, then proceeded to bash her head against the tile until she died.

3. Ryder May

- Killed by: Unknown man (presumably)

- Cause of death: Throat slit off screen

Ryder showed up to the reunion and was seen mingling with the other former students. Ryder was unable to make his mark on the reunion as he was promptly murdered off screen by the masked man. His throat was slit and his body was stuffed into one of the lockers, which Gemma, Ash, and Blake all walked by, not noticing the blood dripping out from the bottom.

4. Heather Weathers

- Killed by: Unknown man

- Cause of death: Stabbed 5 times

Heather, in an attempt to avoid speaking to anyone else at the reunion, snuck off to make a phoen call to her mother. Unable to find service, however, she attempted to go outside to get better signal, only to find that the door was chained from the outside. When she turned to go back, she collided with teh man in black, who narrowly stabbed her. Luckily, Heather escaped and led a cat-and-mouse chase to the girls locker room, where she hid in one of the lockers. Heather thought she was safe when the man in black walked past the locker she was in; unfortunately, her Jenny Craig representative Angela decided to call her back, which alerted the killer to her location. He opened the locker, stabbed her once in the stomach, threw her to the ground, then stabbed her again in the chest. He then stabbed her 3 more times before she finally died.

5. Valerie Carlson

- Killed by: Unknown man

- Cause of death: Stabbed repeatedly in the back

Tired from dancing, Valerie decided to take a break and grab a drink from the snacks table. While there, she saw her reflection in her phone's screen, deciding she desperately needed a touch up. So, she went alone to the bathroom, but stopped short from going inside when she heard a screeching noise. When she investigated, she found nothing, but upon turning around, she was met with the man in black. He sliced her arm but she managed to scramble away, running down the hall and going to the first room she found, calling for help. Unfortunately, nobody could hear her over the music. Before she could run into the room, the man caught up to her and stabbed her in the back, forcing her through the doorway and onto the floor. She attempted to crawl away, but the man caught up and stomped on the knife, pressing it further into her back. He then pulled it out and began to stab her in the back multiple times until she died.

6. Brenda Anderson

- Killed by: Unknown man

- Cause of death: Stabbed repeatedly in the stomach

Brenda was taking a trip down memory lane in one of the art classrooms, looking at different pieces her and her friends created when they were in school. She heard someone enter the classroom and looked up to see the man in black. Thinking it was Jay pulling another one of his usual pranks, Brenda told him off and attempted to walk past him. The man, however, grabbed her by the throat and threw her against the floor, then kicked her in the face. He proceeded to grab her by the neck again, slamming her into a filing cabinet and smashing her head against the glass of a framed picture before pinning her to the wall by her throat. He pulled out his knife and proceeded to stab her multiple times in the stomach before dropping her dead body to the ground.