These are face claims that have already been chosen or are of characters in the past. Duplicates are not allowed. The list will be updated as needed.

Shailene Woodley
Annasophia Robb
Evan Peters
Joey Graceffa
Kellin Quinn
Chanel Iman
Nina Dobrev
Teresa Palmer
Daniel Sharman
Leighton Meester
Jensen Ackles
Dylan O'Brien
Renato Ferreira
Brittany Snow
Thomas Dekker
Josh Hutcherson
Jake Gyllenhaal
Hayden Panettiere
Nico Tortorella
Danielle Campbell
Katerina Graham
Dean Geyer
Ariana Grande
Michael Trevino
Trevor Donovan
Britt Robertson
Victoria Justice
Haley Pullos
Chord Overstreet
Logan Lerman
Ali Michael
Ashley Benson
Matthew Lush
Holland Roden
Zayn Malik
Lily Rabe
Tom Felton
Kylie Bunbury
Gregg Sulkin
Luke Mitchell
Lucy Hale
Brant Daugherty
Sam Claflin
Taylor Lautner
Greg Finley