Then after winning immunity, Tasha left and he was all alone. Final 5. He wins reward with Kass and Woo, and puts a plan in motion to take out Tony's legs, Trish. This succeeds after even Tony votes her out.
He didn't win reward at final 5 with kass and woo, he won it at final 6 and the plan was to take out trish then butttttttttttt it failed and they didnt go with him. Then because spencer won immunity at final 5 tony took out trish
blueu22 was that final 6? sorry, since ive only watched Cagayan once I don't know EXACT timed placed events. I feel good about remembering most of Cagayan however.
NegaSub Wait you have Spencer on this list and not Tony? You can have both, but you can't have Spencer above Tony. Tony was in control the entire game and Spencer no matter how hard he tried was always in the minority. I think Spencer played well, but not better than Tony
adamsel - I said One Per season . Tony did play a great game, but in my opinion, Spencer played with more honor and respect than Tony, and thats why I chose Spencer over Tony. Both played a great game, and Spencer took better use of opportunities than Tony
negasub I feel like Tony was given more opportunities to backstab people. All of spencer's allies were being eliminated so he never really had a chance to backstab anyone. I feel like if he had the chance, he would have. For example, I've seen in interviews that Alexis thought of Spencer as her closest allie on the swapped tribe and then he backstbbed her by voting her out. It just wasn't shown that way because it wouldn't have been relevent to the story line
adamsel well Alexis and Spencer had the Chicago part close to them. She would feel close because of that. Both spencer and tony were given plenty of opportunities to make moves to completely further their game. Yes, Tony did make finals, but he could have easily had a different path. A more honorable and respectable path. He won for a reason, I wish more people who played would win, but Spencer had a more respectable game
The fact that you put that Spencer opportunities to get LJ/Jefra out. I'll give him credit for playing into Tony's paranoia for Jefra's blindside, but Spencer had NOTHING to do with the blindside of LJ except for you know voting him.
dragotistic - I have said in comments above I agree Tony played a great game. However, the fact that he had no respect or honor in his gameplay whatsoever is what didn't get him a spot. He also never took advantage of more opportunities to make moves to better his game or you know any respect in it. I do agree he played a fantastic game, that rivals Russell. But Russell, when you look at it, did have an ounce of respect, especially seen in Samoa.
sahmosean - I know - but the way he played the game this one time just really gave me faith in new survivors again, along with one other person on this list.
negasub I absolutely agree.
But it's obvious that he's coming back so I wouldn't think of him as a "one-time player" its temporary
I guess we thought that about Terry though (he better be on your list btw)
