After the females finally take a loss to the men, half of the team wondered if they should keep themselves strong to prevent the men from starting to gain confidence and powerful them, or vote out an early threat. Fluttershy, as usual, was deemed by Heather, Jenna and Vecepia to be weak and a liability, which put the pony on the chopping block. However, knowing just how good she turned out to be during season 4, Ursala pulled Fluttershy in and promised her that she would be safe if she worked with her. Since Trixie was not around for Fluttershy this time, she had no choice but to trust Ursala, since she didn't want to be voted out quickly yet again. There was no Redemption Island this time around.
Wanting to seize control and get rid of the threats first, Ursala got Kuki and Lindsay to join her side almost immediately, since she considered both of them quite stupid and easy to manipulate. Needing at least two more for majority, Kuki got Fluttershy to work her cuteness on Ann and Elissa. Even though Fluttershy didn't really know what Ursala meant, she somehow accomplished her mission and got Ann and Elissa to fall head over heels for her and join their alliance. Now with the numbers on her side, Ursala thought about who to target between Heather, Jenna, Julie and Vecepia.
At tribal council, Heather was the vocal one and had no problem calling out Fluttershy, Kuki and Lindsay for being pathetic and utterly useless in the grand scheme of things. Fluttershy began to cry, and was quickly consoled by basically everyone in her alliance, other than the amused Ursala. Lindsay calls Heather a few choice names, and Kuki calls her a bully. Having predicted this, Ursala decided to keep Heather around to keep a big target around camp just in case they had to go back to tribal soon. Instead, Ursala made her alliance target Jenna Morasca instead. After the vote, Jenna was blindsided 6-4 over Fluttershy and eliminated from the game.
Warriors Tribe:
Colby Donaldson (Season 1, 4th Place)
Jack Spicer (Season 4, 13th Place)
Jeff Probst (Season 2, 3rd Place)
Jim ( sahmosean) (Season 3, 3rd Place)
Nick Bradley ( NickBrad97) (Season 3, 7th Place)
Rob ( titanium162) (Season 3, 2nd Place)
Russell Hantz (Season 2, 2nd Place)
Seto Kaiba (Season 4, 2nd Place)
Trying to make it two in a row, the men fail miserably as Fluttershy and the ladies bounce back rather handily to send the Warriors to their third tribal council in four tries. Easy to say, no one is pleased about this, except for the women of course.
