Completing his amazing comeback, Nick Bradley won the final immunity challenge as the last man standing to make the finale. The girls would once again have to turn on one another. Heather knew about Lindsay and Nick forming a romantic relationship, and realized she could use that to her advantage in the final three by claiming they were more focused on one another while she herself did all the work. So, she had to target Fluttershy, who could very well get a few votes tossed her way out of respect for making two straight final threes. Fluttershy was already planning on voting out Heather, since she just didn't want a mean girl like her to make the end over a nice girl like Lindsay. So it would come down to whatever Lindsay and Nick thought was best. As Lindsay nonchalantly took a naked bath in the nearby spring, Nick was forced to turn away while speaking to her. Both discussed what it would mean to take either Fluttershy or Heather to the end. Fluttershy was heavily liked, but once again her game-play could easily be questioned. Heather was heavily disliked, but easily played the best game after Ursala left.
At tribal council, Fluttershy and Heather pretty much knew it was one of them becoming the final member of the curious jury. Heather pointed out how the jury loves Fluttershy and will want to vote for her to give her the win that Trixie took from her last season. Fluttershy meekly stated that Heather was very mean, but she played a very powerful game that the jury could easily respect more over her weaker one. Lindsay stupidly asked if this meant she was in the final three, and Nick pretty much informed her it did. As the final four all voted, the jury of All-Stars all held their breaths in anticipation. Fluttershy and Heather both received the first votes, before the final two votes were revealed to be for Heather. The Total Drama goddess screamed in righteous fury as she became the final jury member with a 3-1 unanimous vote.
You are now voting for a WINNER! Who do you want to see win the All-Star season 5 of Total Drama Survivor Crossover? Will it be Fluttershy, Lindsay, or Nick Bradley?
Fluttershy has now made back-to-back final threes, after finishing in 3rd place in season 4. After losing so badly last season for not doing enough, Fluttershy tried to be more assertive and aggressive this season. While she did make some decisions for herself, and did get a bit more aggressive when constantly being manipulated, was it enough to warrant her to win All-Stars? She has no real enemies on the jury, but she is still just a female pony who some people could mock. She has two individual immunity wins.
Lindsay played in the very first season of Total Drama Survivor Crossover, and barely lost to winner Noah in a 4-3 vote, winding up in a respectable 2nd place. Much like Fluttershy, Lindsay is typically very likeable and nice, if not really dimwitted and stupid most of the time. Despite always being in the majority thanks to being in the right place at the right time, Lindsay formed a romantic relationship with Nick Bradley that helped her make the end, too. Is that a good thing or a bad thing? She has one individual immunity win.
Nick Bradley played in season 3, finishing in 7th place, and thus is the only finalist to not have made a previous finale. Nick Bradley is an expert at finding hidden immunity idols, having gotten his hands on two of the three in the game, the first of which was used correctly to save himself from being eliminated. Nick is not only the last man standing, but is the last Tengaged player standing, too. While typically a klutzy goofball, Nick is still fairly liked by most everyone, and got a lot of attention from Lindsay this season, including some kisses and cleavage sighting. Nick won the most individual immunity challenges with three, all of which were crucial for him to survive to the end.
WHO DO YOU WANT TO WIN THIS ALL-STAR SEASON? VOTE FOR A WINNER!
