It was time for the powerful 301+ Tribe to go to tribal council, and no one was happy about it. Buckley angrily let everyone on the tribe know how useless they were, and made sure to point out all their flaws so that they could try and improve on them. Oddly enough, despite what an asshole he was being, most everyone found Buckley's insults to be endearing and began to use it as motivation to better next time. Later, it was revealed that Doug Walker had gotten the tribe's first Subscriber Idol, and he was overjoyed by the support. Felix began to entertain the tribe by acting like the clown he was, which infuriated Buckley and led to a very hilarious confessional consisting of a very rude rant filled with a lot vulgarity and insults. Anthony and Toby began to entertain the tribe as well, both being performers, and this just further angered Buckley.
Being the most sane of the male tribe-mates, Buckley and Doug both discussed on what they should and what Doug was going to do with the idol. After much deliberation, Doug said that he was going to use it to make his vote count as two. Buckley liked this idea, and said they should vote out a weak girl first, much like the other tribe did, since it clearly helped them out in the last challenge. Doug wasn't sure, since he felt like taking out Felix would be smarter, since he was like a god to so many people and him going sooner rather than later would be ideal. Buckley admitted that he hated pretty much everyone on the tribe, so he didn't care who went, as it would be one less headache to deal with.
At tribal council, Felix stole the show and amused everyone except Buckley and Doug by acting like he usually did on YouTube. Jenna and Justine then went on to say that voting anyone out on a tribe with amazing people like all of them would be hard, but they should vote unanimously so that there wouldn't be any tribe dysfunction. Buckley was asked who on the tribe deserved to go first, to which he gave a very elaborate and detailed speech on the three weakest girls (Kandee, Michelle and Natalie) and the three most annoying males (Anthony, Felix and Toby) and said any of those six leaving would be perfect. When Doug joined in and said he was using his idol to count as two votes, the jokes and playful banter stopped and everyone grew nervous about what was going to happen. When it came time to vote, it was clear that most everybody was in sync with one another, despite how different some of them were. Doug two votes went toward Michelle, but they didn't matter, as everyone else voted for her as well. Michelle was voted out 10-1 over Natalie.
Google Plus Tribe:
Brittani Taylor (Brittani Louise Taylor)
Christina Grimmie (Zeldaxlove64)
James Rolfe (Cinemassacre)
Matthew Patrick (The Game Theorists)
Megan Flores (Megannicolesite)
Phil Mason (PMRants)
Ray Johnson (Ray William Johnson)
Rebecca Brayton (WatchMojo)
Shane Dawson (Shane Dawson)
301+ Tribe:
Adam Buckley (A Dose Of Buckley)
Anthony Padilla (Smosh)
Doug Walker (The Nostalgia Critic)
Felix Kjellberg (PewDiePie)
Jenna Mourey (Jenna Marbles)
Justine Ezarik (IJustine)
Kandee Johnson (Kandee Johnson)
Natalie Tran (Communitychannel)
Toby Turner (Tobuscus)
After voting out one of their weakest girls, the 301+ Tribe copying the Google Plus Tribe's strategy paid off. They got a bounce-back win, sending the latter tribe right back to tribal council once more.
VOTE TO GIVE THE SUBSCRIBER IDOL TO SOMEONE ON THE GOOGLE PLUS TRIBE, BUT ALSO VOTE OUT SOMEONE FROM THE VERY SAME TRIBE! YOU CANNOT VOTE THE SAME PERSON ON BOTH!
VOTED OUT PLAYER: Christina Grimmie