Only including seasons 21-29 that have played once sorry andrea
SJDS:
1st: Natalie (Villain)
4th: Keith (Hero)
6th: Jon (Could be either...)
8th: Reed (Villain?)
10th: Jeremy (Hero)
-2nd C's-
14th: Kelley
Cagayan:
1st: Tony (Villain)
3rd: Kass (Villain)
4th: Spencer (Hero)
-2nd C's-
6th: Tasha (Could also be hero)
10th: Morgan (Unlikely but pleaseee)
11th: Sarah
Blood VS Water:
5th: Ciera (Hero)
7th: Hayden (Hero)
-2nd C's-
13th: John