1. Kim Spradlin
2. Sandra Diaz-Twine
3. Richard Hatch
4. Natalie Anderson
5. Tony Vlachos
6. James "J.T." Thomas, Jr.
7. Todd Herzog
Anyone who you think I looked over comment below...
ps. I automatically eliminated everyone who won on their second try, due to them getting outwitted, outlasted and outplayed their first season
For those who wish to know I would rank...
Tina 15...she played great her first season, but couldn't pull it off in her several other ones
and Jeremy 11th, he played amazing his second season, but couldn't pull it off in his first
AdamRuinsEverything He definitely did not his first season though, arguably his second, but looking over his total performance he got outwitted and had to try again