With no prior returnees up to date these would probably be my picks because all these people showed in some way they had a potential to play well or never got a fair shot imo
Survivor second chance cast:
Men:
Rory Freeman ~ Survivor Vanuatu (placed 10th)
Jonathan Libby ~ Survivor Palau (placed 20/19)
Aaron Reisberger ~ Survivor China (placed 12th)
Spencer Duhm ~ Survivor Tocantins (placed 12th)
Matt Quinlan ~ Survivor One World (placed 16th)
Max Dawson ~ Survivor Worlds Apart (placed 14th)
John Cody ~Survivor Blood Vs Water (Placed 13th)
Matty Whitmore ~ Survivor Gabon (placed 4th)
Charlie Herschel ~ Survivor Gabon (placed 9th)
Jason Siska ~ Survivor Micronesia ( placed 8th)
Women:
Tracy Hughes-Wolfe ~ Survivor Micronesia (placed 12th)
Sierra Reed ~ Survivor Tocantins (placed 7th)
Kourtney Moon ~ Survivor One World (placed 18th)
Allie Pohevitz ~ Survivor Caramoan (placed 19th)
Alexis Maxwell ~ Survivor Cagayan (placed 12th)
Anna Khait ~Survivor Kaoh Rong (placed 13th)
Mari Takahashi ~ Survivor Millenials Vs Gen-X (Placed 19th)
Mikayla Wingle ~ Survivor South Pacific (placed 14th)
Wanda Shirk ~ Survivor Palau (placed 19/20)
Alecia Holden ~ Survivor Kaoh Rong (Placed 14th)