CharlieBibi selects Bins 1 and 8
HowLovely selects Bins 8 and 11

Bins:

1: 1810
8: James Madison
11: 1828

CharlieBibi makes a match with 1810 and James Madison.

Bins:

         2      3      4      5
6      7              9     10
11    12    13    14     15
16    17    18    19     20

Matches:

0-HowLovely
1-CharlieBibi

We are playing to 5.

You may MAIL ME your next matchings

Yay me :)

Shoot.

CharlieBibi selects Bins 2 and 17
HowLovely selects Bins 5 and 17

Bins:

2: 1905
5: 1893
17: John F. Kennedy

No match.

Bins:

         2      3      4      5
6      7              9     10
11    12    13    14     15
16    17    18    19     20

Matches:

0-HowLovely
1-CharlieBibi

We are playing to 5.

You may MAIL ME your next matchings

HowLovely selects Bins 14 and 15
CharlieBibi selects Bins 3 and 7

Bins:

3: Benjamin Harrison
7: 1987
14: Ronald Reagan
15: 1974

No match.

Bins:

         2      3      4      5
6      7              9     10
11    12    13    14     15
16    17    18    19     20

Matches:

0-HowLovely
1-CharlieBibi

We are playing to 5.

You may MAIL ME your next matchings

HowLovely selects Bins 15 and 17
CharlieBibi selects Bins 7 and 14

Bins:

7: 1987
14: Ronald Reagan
15: 1974
17: John F. Kennedy

CharlieBibi makes a match with 1987 and Ronald Reagan.

Bins:

         2      3      4      5
6                      9     10
11    12    13             15
16    17    18    19     20

Matches:

0-HowLovely
2-CharlieBibi

We are playing to 5.

You may MAIL ME your next matchings

Ok I suck at this.

CharlieBibi selects Bins 3 and 5
HowLovely selects Bins 10 and 15

Bins:

3: Benjamin Harrison
5: 1893
10: 1866
15: 1974

CharlieBibi makes a match with 1893 and Benjamin Harrison.

Bins:

         2             4     
6                      9     10
11    12    13            15
16    17    18    19     20

Matches:

0-HowLovely
3-CharlieBibi

We are playing to 5.

You may MAIL ME your next matchings

Wtf.

Sorry :/

CharlieBibi selects Bins 19 and 20
HowLovely selects Bins 9 and 20

Bins:

9: Andrew Johnson
19: Woodrow Wilson
20: 1841

No match.

Bins:

         2             4     
6                      9     10
11    12    13            15
16    17    18    19     20

Matches:

0-HowLovely
3-CharlieBibi

We are playing to 5.

You may MAIL ME your next matchings

Pretty sure I got both decoys. If I say it do I get bonus points? :X

CharlieBibi selects Bins 9 and 10
HowLovely selects Bins 6 and 15

Bins:

6: John Quincy Adams
9: Andrew Johnson
10: 1866
15: 1974

CharlieBibi makes a match with 1866 and Andrew Johnson.

Bins:

         2             4     
6                     
11    12    13            15
16    17    18    19     20

Matches:

0-HowLovely
4-CharlieBibi (NEEDS ONE MORE TO WIN)

We are playing to 5.

You may MAIL ME your next matchings

17 and 20 were the decoys amirite?

You won
I didn't really care
Bye opposite worlds