It was time for the Outcast twist, with the ten eliminated contestants all getting to vote for one of their own to reenter the game. The two players with the top votes would make up the final 12 and merge with the remaining contestants. Rob and Ryan both could not return due to their injuries, but both still got to cast a vote for who they wanted to see get back into the game. After the vote, it was revealed that Nick Newman and Elissa Slater were the two returnees! The goofball Tengaged user and the beloved Big Brother star both happily returned to the game as the remaining All-Stars merged into the Galaxy Tribe.
With the group of 12 All-Stars going at it in the first individual immunity challenge, everyone was fighting as hard as they could. Yet, the winner came from the most unlikely source. Through all the muscle and fortitude from all the strong players, Fluttershy somehow pulls out a shocking immunity win.
