On her daily walk to collect firewood over at the Pagan camp, Cindy found an idol and shares this information with her closest ally: Grandma. Grandma uses this to form a three person alliance including Comet to try and take control of the tribe.
At the Christian camp Melchoir blows up on Pope for flipping on them. Balthazar tries to mitigate the damage with Pope and explains to him that the Jesus trio needs to be split up. He suggests Joseph as the easiest person to flip.
At the challenge Cindy can not sit out and costs the Pagans the win, sending them to their first tribal.
Before tribal, Santa approaches Fairy and tells her the majority are going to vote Cindy for being the weakest at challenges. Feeling left out she meets with the minority alliance and tells them of the vote.
Having discussed the idol play, Fairy voted for Cindy to deceive the majority alliance and Snowman was idol'd out with 3 votes against him.
Rankings:
1. Cindy Lou
2. Fairy
3. Pope
4. Grandma
5. Santa (LMAOO HIS DUMBASS STORYLINE CONTINUES. HE FUCKS UP EVERYTHING)
6. Balthazar
7. Comet
8. Melchoir
9. Mary
10. Gingerbread Man
11. Nutcracker
12. Jesus
13. Joseph