After Mulan somehow lost to a yellow talking pony and an obnoxious boy genius and was eliminated from the game, Fluttershy and Jack Spicer spent their first awkward night alone together on Redemption Island. Jack attempted to make some playful chit-chat involving his evil deeds, but this just made Fluttershy uncomfortable. Fluttershy, in turn, attempted to talk to Jack about the joys of animals and how sweet they were, but this just made Jack make fake gagging noises. It was a very uneventful night.
Back on the dejected Sub-Villains, everyone felt very relieved that the biggest annoyance on their team was now gone. However, when Sofia ended up injuring herself by falling out of a tree while trying to gather coconuts, everyone began to immediately regret their decision to vote out arguably their strongest player. Kaiba and Yugi both remained as secret partners, and began to debate on who they would eliminate next. Knowing that the idiot Patrick would do whatever they said, the card-dueling boys decided to target one of the women should they lose. Harley Quinn was most likely the evilest person left on their tribe, while Sofia was incredibly weak and would most likely continue to hurt them should they keep her around. Pikachu just felt lost by this point and had no idea what he was doing anymore.
With the high-riding Anti-Heroes, Trixie continued to be the target of everyone's attention as they kept playing for her swing vote. The mare still couldn't fully decide on which side she wanted to support, since one side aggravated her to no end and had stupid people (the heroes), while the villains made her very uncomfortable and were really nasty. She decided to talk to the self-appointed "leader" of each side to try and understand their logic of thinking better. Not to mention see where Trixie would stand going deep into the game with said side. Batman informed Trixie that should she make the right choice, she would be welcomed with open arms by the heroes and be seen as nothing less of one, and would be treated as an equal all the way to the end. Ursala explained to Trixie that being good was nice for making friends, but winning a brutal game like Survivor took risks and big moves, and sticking with those who were too nice or didn't want to get their hands bloody would never allow her to make it far.
Following yet another Anti-Heroes challenge win, the Sub-Villains were really regretting voting out Jack. Omi, for some really stupid reason, attempted to get himself sent to Exile Island, but since he was on the winning tribe, that couldn't happen. This time, instead of sending the weak Sofia to exile to make the vote hard, the Anti-Heroes chose to exile Patrick Star instead. In return, Kaiba decided to kidnap Trixie from the Anti-Heroes, since losing Patrick for the next vote really put his plans with Yugi in jeopardy and this would be a great time to influence Trixie's decisions down the road.
Once Trixie joined the Sub-Villains for the night, Kaiba and Yugi immediately began to talk with her about helping them vote out a villain tonight. Yugi explains that, while Kaiba was viewed as a villain himself, he could still put their differences aside for the greater good and help one another out. This made Trixie realize that simply picking a side was not the right thing to think about. She realized that both sides had their flaws, but ultimately neither side was right OR wrong. All Trixie had to do was pick people that she felt she could trust, good OR evil, and attempt to work with them as best as she could. Trixie agreed to help out Kaiba and Yugi, and thanks to Pikachu just being glad to be useful, they now had a 4-2 advantage and they began to debate on who to vote out between Harley and Sofia, the two villain girls.
At tribal council, both Harley and Sofia saw the writing on the wall and they knew that they were both on the chopping block. Both women attempted to explain why they should be kept over the other. Harley explained that Batman was most likely running the show on the other side, and without her around to help take him out, they would all fall one by one to the dark knight. Sofia basically fell upon the sword and admitted that she was injured, weak, and downright exhausted with this game and she was nothing more but a vote for anybody to use. Ultimately, realizing that they still had a free boot even if they lost yet another challenge, the alliance of Kaiba, Pikachu, Trixie and Yugi voted for Harley Quinn. Sofia's vote made it unanimous, and Harley Quinn was sent to Redemption Island 5-1.
On Redemption Island, Jack immediately began to laugh his head off at Harley Quinn joining them, not caring one bit about mocking anyone from his former tribe being voted off. Harley responded by beating Jack senseless, and since the production crew found this warranted, they decided to NOT eject Harley from the game for that. Fluttershy just trembled in the corner and asked herself why creatures from the other worlds had to act so cruel like this. Ultimately, Fluttershy continued her hot streak on Redemption Island and won yet another duel, and despite Jack getting beaten up, he STILL managed to beat Harley Quinn and stay alive as well. This finally eliminated the villainous woman from the game.
Redemption Island:
Fluttershy (My Little Pony)
Jack Spicer (Xiaolin Showdown)
Anti-Heroes Tribe:
Batman (Batman)
Eric Cartman (South Park)
Kuki Sanban (Codename: Kids Next Door)
Omi (Xiaolin Showdown)
Roger Klotz (Doug)
Trixie (My Little Pony)
Ursala (The Little Mermaid)
Sub-Villains Tribe:
Patrick Star (Spongebob)
Pikachu (Pokemon)
Seto Kaiba (Yu-Gi-Oh)
Sofia Lamb (Bioshock 2)
Yugi Muto (Yu-Gi-Oh)
The Sub-Villains continued to be in self-destruct mode as they lost their third straight challenge, making their dwindling tribe of five soon to be four.
Batman
Sofia lamb