Here is a list of 20 Survivors, who on the list does not deserve to be considered the best?
Rob Cesternino
Parvati Shallow
Cirie Fields
Boston Rob Mariano
Todd Herzog
Richard Hatch
Malcolm Freberg
Brian Heidik
Jonny Fairplay
Yul Kwon
Chris Daughtery
Sandra Diaz-Twine
Stephen Fishbach
J.T. Thomas
Earl Cole
Denise Stapley
Danni Boatwright
Ethan Zohn
Kim Spradlin
Tom Westman
karolusmagnus Not Tom? I can see why no Ethan or Malcolm, but I think Tom did an amazing job in Palau, and really controlled the game, and the lesser players in it
But Palau really had no good players, and essentially no strategy until final 4 or 5
Tom went through the least amount of tribals, and the votes offs were totally cliquish. First all of Ulong left. Then because Koror had gone so long without tribals, the "alliances" had formed based purely on who was cool. After there was only cool kids left, all Tom - Ian - Katie did was join against the obvious romantic pair. Tom's only real strong move was being an asshole to Ian.
karolusmagnus No season has many good players :P I see your point, but his control of Caryn really shows his social skills, and Ian was always acting as an assistant manager to Tom, and mix that with perfect immunity wins, he really took down that season.
See that BostonRob_ that's how normal people talk about Survivor
Johnny Fairplay does not deserve to be on here. He quit! NO quitter deserves to be called one of the 20 best players ever. Fairplay should be replaced by Russell.
masterchef ya it is, but his quit in the second season doesn't negate his first season. That's why Richard Hatch is still one of the best players ever. How could you like Russell if you counted his third appearance in any seriousness?
