We all hate All-Star seasons, but if there were a themed season I strongly believe that this concept is the best.
The concept is simple, a season full of the people who made it to the final 3 OR final 4, depending on whether it were a final 2 or final 3 respectively. This graveyard is chock full of fan-favorites and strong players in this position, and the field is full of great options for an All-Star season.
Christina Cha (fuck ya Cha Cha!)
Kathy Vavrick O'Brien
Jenna Lewis
Cirie Fields
Erinn Lobdell
Jerri Manthey
Holly Hoffman
Ashley Underwood
Denise Martin
Ozzy Lusth
Yau-man Chan
Rafe Judkins
Terry Deitz
Rob Cesternino
Johnny "Fairplay" Dalton
Lex van den Berghe
Malcolm Freberg
Eddie Fox
Some weird choices because the genders need to be balanced. I stand by Eddie being in the cast too :P
Christina was terrible. She gave up at the final four. Ashley was just one of Rob's zombies, Denise Martin did nothing, and Lex was a bitter baby on season 8. Love the rest of your picks though!
notforsaken
But here's the difference between Andrea and Ashley. Andrea showed promise on her first season. Ashley showed no promise whatsoever. She said in exit interviews that she never made any strategic moves because it seemed too "sneaky".
